Sunday, April 20, 2014

Left or Right-wing Extremists: The Bellowing Giants


If there is one Biblical story that has captured the imaginations of generations of Christians, Jews and even the nonreligious, it is the account of David and Goliath.  The story is often used to illustrate how an underdog can overcome a more powerful, conditioned, and skilled foe.  We like to associate our struggles against overwhelming odds with the young shepherd with a sling and stone, facing down a battle-clad giant.  “If David can win, so can we” becomes locker room speech.  But, as Malcolm Gladwell writes about in his book, David and Goliath: Underdogs, Misfits, and the Art of Battling Giants and discusses here during a TedTalk, David may not have been such an underdog, and Goliath may not have had as strong of advantage as we sometimes think.

Imagine being a soldier in the army of Israel.  For 40 days, morning and evening, Goliath taunted the army.  80 times they had heard Goliath and each time they were left “dismayed and terrified.”  There was surely some brash, guy talk of taking on the giant, but it had never gotten to the action stage.  I can hear murmurs of, “Someone should do something.”  But, for 40 days no one did anything.

Regardless of the circumstances, it is easy for us to relate to David.  How many times have we stepped onto the field of “battle” and felt we were at a disadvantage?  Even though we may be competent with our “sling and five stones” and have a proven record of success against bears and lions, a giant is still intimidating.

The radicals at the extreme political left and right have taken a cue from Goliath, bellowing taunts across the valley floor.  Is it me, but does everyone on Fox News seem to be yelling and those on National Public Radio (NPR) speak in an exasperated tone?  Both extremes seem determined to communicate how appalled and outraged they find themselves.

But, is there substance to the appalled and outraged “Goliaths” or do they resort to hyperbole simply to pull us closer to their position?  Does every government assistance program truly undermine the work ethic of America?  Do common sense statutes and rules about firearm ownership and possession mean that we have just climbed on the slip and slide and are careening toward the government kicking down the door to take our guns?  Will bans on high capacity magazines have any impact on what some repeatedly refer to as “gun violence?”  Should we function as the world’s police force or stick with issues here in the U.S.?

So, these “Goliaths” walk down to the valley floor day after day, with the taunt of “I dare you to take me on.”  They shore up their taunts with labels.  To defy them makes one a liberal, a conservative; un-American, a patriot; a right or a left-winger.  In the Biblical account, Goliath was led onto the field by his armor bearer.  The modern Goliaths scream out their threats and all their little minions begin to flood the inboxes of their target with prewritten emails. 

Those of us in the conservation and law enforcement field spend a great deal of resources dealing with these self-proclaimed giants.  I recall a meeting with a legislator about reports from his constituents concerning wildlife officers patrolling a lake in his district.  These callers were affluent, influential people in a gated community who felt that they should be left alone to do as they pleased.  The legislator’s final words to me were, “I want the phone calls to stop.  I don’t care what you do or how you do it, but I want the calls to stop.”  He was tired of hearing the giants’ taunts.

Whether Gladwell is correct in his assessment of Goliath’s medical condition and David’s skills made him less of an underdog than some think, or if we view David as divinely ordained to slay the Philistine to elevate him to a position of leadership in Israel; the giant still fell.  Not only did he fall, seeing their champion dead, all Philistines turned and ran.  All it took was a shepherd delivering food to his brothers to say, “Let no one lose heart on account of this Philistine; your servant will go and fight him.”

David saw an opening that left Goliath vulnerable to attack, a small gap in the armor on his helmet.  Instead of being paralyzed to the point of inaction, we should be looking for those gaps and exploit them.  David moved forward in a spirit of righteousness so we should always question our motives for taking on giants.

I hope you will forgive a little reading between the lines, but I like to think that just before letting loose that stone, David switched to the King James English and told Goliath, “And now I shall kick thine ass.”  We have all wanted to say that many times.  Maybe it is time that we (figuratively) do just that.


No comments:

Post a Comment